The concept of setting a minimum wage above equilibrium sounds straightforward: raise the pay, and lift the standard of living.
But when we dig a little deeper, the plot thickens.
According to Principles of Economics by N. Gregory Mankiw (2021), when a minimum-wage law requires wages to remain above the equilibrium level, the result is often a surplus of labor or unemployment. This occurs because the higher wage rate increases the number of job seekers but reduces the number of positions employers are willing to offer, particularly impacting low-skilled workers.
In this post, we’ll explore what happens When a Minimum-Wage Law Forces The Wage To Remain Above The Equilibrium Level, The Result Is, giving you a clear picture of the economic results and the ripple effects on both workers and businesses.
What Exactly Is Equilibrium Wage?
Before we dive into the effects, let’s clarify some basics.
The equilibrium wage is the “happy medium” in a free market, where the supply of labor (people looking for work) meets the demand (businesses looking to hire).
Here, employment is at its most efficient; companies get the workers they need, and people get the jobs they’re seeking.
Setting Minimum Wage Above Equilibrium
When the government sets a minimum wage that’s higher than this equilibrium level, they’re essentially mandating that all workers should earn a certain amount, regardless of whether that amount aligns with what the market can support.
This is done to ensure workers earn a livable wage, but it can trigger some unintended consequences.
What Happens When Minimum Wage Stays Above Equilibrium?
When a minimum wage law forces wages above equilibrium, we start to see some predictable patterns emerge in the labor market. Let’s walk through them.
👉🏼 The Labor Surplus (Or Unemployment)
Here’s the kicker: as soon as the minimum wage is above the equilibrium wage, businesses need fewer workers.
Why? Because higher wages mean higher costs. So, to cut back, companies might start laying off employees or reduce the number of hours they offer.
Increased Labor Supply: More people are interested in working because of the higher pay.
Decreased Labor Demand: Businesses, on the other hand, hire less because it’s more expensive.
Result: Unemployment. You have more people looking for jobs than there are positions available, leading to a surplus of labor.
For example, a coffee shop that used to hire ten baristas may now only be able to afford seven, leaving three people out of a job. Sure, the seven who stay are happy with their higher pay, but for those three, it’s a different story.
👉🏼 Business Adaptation: Automation and Cost-Cutting
Businesses are resourceful, and when faced with higher wages, they adapt. Sometimes, this means turning to technology or changing the way they operate.
Automation: With wage costs up, businesses look for alternatives like self-checkout kiosks, automated ordering systems, or even robots for tasks that used to require human hands.
Restructuring: Companies may also change roles or reduce hours to manage costs more effectively.
Ever wondered why fast-food chains are so quick to adopt self-checkout kiosks? It’s a way to balance higher wage mandates without needing as many employees on the floor.
👉🏼 Price Increases for Consumers
Higher wages don’t just affect the business—they affect you, the consumer.
Passing Costs to Consumers: Companies may raise their prices to cover the increased wage expenses.
Think about it: if a small diner’s expenses rise due to wage laws, they might hike up the price of a burger by a dollar. It’s a small increase, but it adds up over time, making things slightly more expensive for everyone.
👉🏼 Fewer Entry-Level Opportunities
When wages rise, employers tend to become pickier about who they hire. This can lead to fewer opportunities for young people, entry-level workers, or those with limited experience.
Experience Barriers: Employers may start looking for candidates who can “justify” the higher wage by bringing more experience to the table.
So, while the intention is to lift everyone up, it may inadvertently shut some people out of the job market entirely. The irony? These laws meant to help workers can make it harder for new workers to get their foot in the door.
Who Benefits and Who Doesn’t – When a Minimum-Wage Law Forces The Wage To Remain Above The Equilibrium Level, The Result Is?
Let’s break down who stands to gain and who might lose out when the minimum wage stays above the equilibrium.
🚩 Beneficiaries
- Employees Who Retain Their Jobs: Those who manage to stay employed benefit from the increased wage and a better standard of living.
- Skilled Laborers: Higher wages can attract workers with more skills and experience, making competition tighter but more favorable for skilled workers.
🚩 Those Affected Negatively
- Unemployed or Underemployed Workers: For people who lose their jobs or can’t find work, the increase in wages is of no benefit.
- Small Business Owners: Higher wages can squeeze profit margins, especially for small businesses that don’t have the resources of big corporations.
Economic Theory Meets Real-World Cases
To see these effects in action, let’s look at some real-world examples.
👉🏼 Seattle’s Minimum Wage Increase
Seattle raised its minimum wage to $15, one of the highest in the U.S. While some workers saw higher incomes, research shows that some businesses cut back on staff and hours. Many entry-level workers actually ended up earning less.
👉🏼 International Examples
Countries like Germany and Canada also have minimum wage laws that impact their economies differently. However, just like in the U.S., they’ve seen similar trends of job reduction in certain industries.
Balancing the Benefits and Drawbacks
The truth is, that minimum wage laws walk a fine line. The goal is to improve workers’ quality of life, but there are ways to lessen the negative impacts on employment.
👉🏼 Policy Adjustments
- Regional Wage Differences: Some states or cities adjust wages based on local economic conditions.
- Gradual Increases: Instead of one big jump, smaller, gradual increases can give businesses more time to adjust.
👉🏼 Alternative Solutions
Rather than focusing solely on minimum wage, some argue for wage subsidies or tax credits for low-income earners, helping to boost income without impacting jobs directly.
🚩 In a civil case, what is the difference between a plaintiff and a defendant
Final Thoughts: When a Minimum-Wage Law Forces The Wage To Remain Above The Equilibrium Level, The Result Is
In the end, when a minimum-wage law forces the wage to stay above the equilibrium level, it creates a ripple effect.
Some workers benefit from a better paycheck, while others face job loss, reduced hours, or higher consumer prices. It’s a balancing act with no perfect solution.
If you’re a business owner, an employee, or someone just interested in economics, understanding these dynamics can help you better navigate this complex landscape.
Minimum wage laws are an ongoing conversation, and each new law brings us closer to finding that balance—so stay tuned and keep the discussion going.
[ When a Minimum-Wage Law Forces The Wage To Remain Above The Equilibrium Level, The Result Is ]